In my experience, the majority of people I encounter in life seem to be at Levels Three and Four—Identity and Internalization. Although the voices of fanaticism are certainly the loudest, those at Level Five seem to represent the minority of the people with whom I have interacted in the Dream of the Planet. However, it is important to notice that each of us moves up and down the levels of attachment during the trajectory of our life, and so we have all experienced different levels of attachment at one time or another.
We can move up and down the levels with awareness and sometimes without awareness, like a child who is hooked on an unpleasant moment until something else happens to divert or redirect their attention. Of course, as adults, our attachments are much stronger than this childlike experience, since we have a tendency to get very comfortable in our beliefs and circumstances. However, we can still change the focal point of our attention if we choose to go through the process of redirection.
Redirection
We must first become aware of where our attention is in the moment. Becoming aware of our attachments is the start of any process; recognizing which beliefs we have either become identified with, internalized, or fanaticized is the first step in moving towards our Authentic Self in any situation. Accepting the truth at that moment is accepting ourselves for who we are, attachments and all. From this point of acceptance, the question will be: “Do I want to keep the attachment?”
If we choose to keep it, and sometimes we will, that is fine, because we are doing so while being aware of the attachment and choosing to live life in that way. If we don’t want to keep it, then we can make a choice to begin to let go. The freedom to choose between these two options is the manifestation of our intent, the power of choice.
As we grow more attached to what we believe, it is much more difficult to see the power of our intent. This is especially true when we have agreements that do not allow us to detach without first judging ourselves for even thinking of changing our mind.
Moving from Level Five to Level Four
In Levels Five and Four, Fanaticism and Internalization, the Dream of the Planet influences the way we view ourselves and how we behave. In other words, domestication reigns above all else. Moving from the extreme point of Fanaticism (the loss of humanity) to Internalization requires the ability to see that our life and all life is more valuable than any idea or belief.
Love and respect for self and others is the beginning to letting go of fanaticism. We cannot give what we do not have; respect for life starts with our own, and love is the grounding source for this respect. Seeing that our life is worth something allows us to see that the life of another individual is just as special. But to let go of the most extreme form of conditional love requires an ability to question the agreements that are tied to it. The act of questioning produces a moment of clarity that allows us to see our truth.
A consequence of this attachment to knowledge at the level of Fanaticism is that we impose self-judgment upon ourselves for even thinking that there may be another way in the form of questioning: For example, how dare I think of any other possibility other than Toltec? I’m a traitor to the philosophy! I should burn for this treachery!
When we are at Level Five, it is difficult to even question our attachments. However, questioning is indeed the way to break through the grip our attachment to knowledge has upon our will. This process is a bit like being on the monkey bars—the only way to move forward is to let go of the bar that is behind us as we propel ourselves forward to reach for the next bar. If we do not let go of the previous bar, we won’t be able to move forward.
A moment of doubt in a belief can be the crack that will begin to expand our perception. Doubt in the form of skepticism with the willingness to learn allows us to withhold our agreement until we have clearly heard and considered everything that pertains to our belief. Skepticism makes it possible to reassess a belief and make a decision to hold on to it by saying yes or no. Remember, there is a yes at the root of every belief we have, but a no can be enough to change our beliefs. Our no is just as powerful as our yes. This is the assertion of our will, and our becoming aware of it allows us the opportunity to no longer be subjugated by our knowledge. Here, we begin to realize that we—not our knowledge—are in control.
To recap, moving from Level Five, Fanaticism, to Level Four, Internalization, requires an awareness of the knowledge we perceive and then asking ourselves: Do I really believe this? Why do I believe this? Does this belief serve me? Reevaluating our beliefs introduces the option to continue to believe or to change. The mere act of exercising choice allows us to once again become aware of our own will. Letting go of Fanaticism is to allow ourselves to listen to what we perceive and reassess our willingness to say yes or no to it with awareness; to choose to redirect the focal point of our attention as we become more aware of the vast possibilities life is offering us. The best way to let go of illusion is to say yes to the truth when it is presented to us.
Moving from Level Four to Level Three
Moving from Level Four, Internalization, to Level Three, Identity, requires that we recognize our attachment to the mechanism of conditional love. Acceptance and rejection itself (our narrators’ distorted commentary) is, according to Toltec tradition, the catalyst for the distortion or corruption of knowledge that allows us to internalize our identity. When we let go of that internal struggle between truth and lies, we cross over to Level Three, Identity. In our tradition, this rebellion represents the birth of a Toltec warrior: when we recognize that the mechanism has a hold of us, we make a choice to not believe in it, thus beginning an internal war for our own personal freedom.
My father’s beautiful work, The Four Agreements, and The Fifth Agreement, a collaboration between my father and my brother don José, as well as the works of many other great spiritual and inspirational teachers and masters from other beautiful traditions, provide us with incredibly useful tools to help us move from Level Four, Internalization, to Level Three, Identity.
For example, when we make the choice to practice the Toltec agreements,
1. Be impeccable with your word
2. Don’t take anything personally
3. Don’t make assumptions
4. Always do your best
5. Be skeptical, but learn to listen
we begin to let go of those agreements and conditions by which we deem ourselves unworthy of our own love and begin to see our attachments from a perspective of objectivity. We also become aware that our attachment to domestication may even tempt us to use these Toltec agreements of personal freedom (or any such tools for transformation) as the conditions of self-acceptance and our acceptance of others. Thus, we distort these tools from the instruments of transformation that they are intended to be into the Five Conditions of our personal freedom.
How do we keep our choice to pursue our personal freedom from becoming the conditions of our own acceptance? We apply the lessons by our own choice and remain aware that they are merely the tools we use to guide our intent as we practice the mastery of our own self-love—in other words, we begin to use knowledge as an instrument to help guide our intent with awareness. This requires a choice to accept ourselves for who we are. The moment we realize that we can love ourselves just the way we are, we can see that domestication is no longer needed; our acceptance is no longer in the future. We are living that love at this moment. Becoming aware of our actions, taking responsibility for our own will, and repenting, if need be, allow us to forgive ourselves and others for our actions and theirs, which helps us to let go of domestication.
Exercise: Using a Labyrinth in the Toltec Tradition
In my family’s Toltec tradition, we practice a method of forgiveness and letting go of our domestication, as well as our emotional wounds and poison, by using the labyrinth—a single-path maze. It is a symbol and ceremony used in various ways by many tribes and traditions of the world. The particular exercise that follows is performed in our Toltec tradition, but it is not the only way to use the labyrinth as a tool for transformation.
Envision yourself at the beginning of the labyrinth. First, you must be willing to enter. If you are not ready to forgive and let go, you have a choice to not enter the labyrinth. This exercise only has power if you say yes by your own will, and by your own will alone will you be able to engage in the exercise. If you do choose to enter, this is the action of saying, “Yes, I am ready to forgive and take responsibility for my own will.”
As you enter the labyrinth, imagine it is a road map of your past that leads to your present moment in life. With every turn, envision a person, a moment, or a belief that you have used in some way to domesticate yourself. What or whom have you used to subjugate your own will in order to be accepted by yourself or others? When you hold that vision in your mind—a person for example—stop, envision him or her, and become aware of how their words have contributed to your domestication and say, “Forgive me. I have used your words to go against myself.” Although that person might have used his or her words and actions to domesticate you, or to cause you harm or pain, you are the one who ultimately said yes to the belief and allowed it to blossom in your mind.
Becoming aware of your responsibility for your half of a relationship is crucial as well—it’s not just the other person’s fault. Recognize that you have been using someone else’s words or past actions to potentially cause both of you harm, simply by saying yes. The action of saying yes is letting their words and actions impact you, allowing them to hurt you or go against you. Their words and actions have power to hurt you only by permission, because you chose to agree with them.
Forgiveness happens the moment you say no to carrying this pain, this weight, this hurt, and let go of it all. Say aloud or to yourself, “Forgive me, I have used your words and actions against myself, and I will no longer use them to hurt myself again.” Forgiveness is the action that allows us to move forward in the labyrinth.
In my case, I can envision people who have judged me for the sake of domestication from their point of view: “Forgive me, I have used your words and actions against myself, and I will no longer use them this way.” Of course I can also see the people who told me the truth, especially when I was hurting myself, and I thank them for their clear reflection of my actions.
Continue through the labyrinth, repeating the same action of forgiveness as new people and situations come to mind—whatever person or wound hooks your attention at that moment. That is the next one you are ready to face and to forgive. As you reach the end of a labyrinth, you may either find yourself at an exit or at a point in the very center. For the sake of this illustration, you will find yourself at the entrance to the center of the labyrinth. Stop here.
Look at the entrance to the center point and envision a mirror. Walk up to that mirror and see your own reflection. When you are ready, repeat these words: “Forgive me, I have used your words most of all to go against myself, and I will no longer use them to hurt myself again.” The action of entering the center point of the labyrinth represents the moment you forgive yourself. This is the action of your own forgiveness and of reclaiming the power, or the impeccability, of your own word—of your own intent. You are worthy of your own forgiveness, as much as you are worthy of your own love.
At this point in this exercise, you have let go of the past by recognizing that the only thing that exists is this present moment. The labyrinth itself is now the past, and you can let it go as you forgive yourself. With awareness, you can now draw the knowledge from your past to make choices in the present moment. The labyrinth expands as you live your life, but the only truth is in that center, that present moment where you are alive. The labyrinth ceremony ends when you recognize that you are worthy of your own love because you are alive in this very moment.
This ceremony is a living symbol; it only has power through our intent. Like the active work of applying the lessons and writings of the masters and teachers who help us heal from our wounds, the labyrinth is meant to represent the active work of letting go of illusion. Letting go of our knowledge in the form of Level Four, Internalization, allows us to once again reclaim our personal freedom from the tyrant of our domestication as we move to the third level of attachment, Identity.
When we are no longer controlled by the distorted voices of our narrators, our identity gives our experiences significance and allows us to understand them by using our knowledge as an effective, helpful tool. Thus, our identity and our knowledge enable us to interact with the Dream of the Planet with a power we do not have when we are at the level of Internalization.
In order for us to relate to and be a part of the Dream of the Planet, knowledge needs to understand us. This is the function of knowledge: it fulfills a need to understand ourselves and the world in which we live. We use it to manage our experience of life and to express our impressions of it. The philosopher René Descartes’ famous proclamation “I think, therefore I am” is the expression of this attachment to identity. But “I think, therefore I am” is uncorrupted by the mechanism of judge and victim since it no longer has to distort knowledge to fit the attachment; it simply describes what is without distortion.
The attachment to identity is the personification of knowledge as ourselves; we call ourselves a concept in an effort to make sense of our complex selves. The moment we let go of our attachment to identity is the moment we become aware of the separation of our being and what we know. Knowledge exists only because we are alive, and our will is the bridge between knowledge and ourselves in the form of our choice between yes and no.
Moving from Level Three to Level Two
Moving from Level Three, Identity, to Level Two, Preference, is the moment we become aware of ourselves without needing to identify ourselves. Level Three is like having a mask you don’t realize you can remove. The moment you understand that the image of the mask is not you, you regain the awareness of your true self—an individual who is completely free to take any direction in life.
At the root of everything that gives form to our belief systems there is a yes. That yes gives life to an idea, a symbol, or a story because it has your intent. Each person’s identity has a meaning because they give it a meaning by agreeing with it. Letting go of the attachment to an identity is recognizing that there is a clear separation between you (the Authentic Self ) and knowledge. That line is your yes and your no; it is your intention.
When you recognize your truth, that you are a living being regardless of what you know, you are free to let go of the attachment of needing to know who you are, because you have the awareness that you are. When you authentically choose how you want to engage in your own life, as well as in the Dream of the Planet, the mask of your identity no longer has to shield your Authentic Self in order to have a voice. You are in control of your intention, your personal dream.
The hallmarks of this level of attachment are that you love yourself unconditionally in this present moment; you play in the Dream of the Planet knowing that your yes and no give life to your art; and you understand that truth exists regardless of whether or not you believe in it, while a belief only exists for as long as you believe in it.
Let’s revisit the imagery of the Smokey Mirror through our Toltec Tradition. We’ve broken through the smoke enough to see the mirror as we let go of Fanaticism; we’ve cleared the smoke as we let go of Internalization; and we’ve become aware that the mirror only reflected the truth as we let go of Identity. Now, as we let go of Preference, we become aware of being the truth that the mirror reflects.
Moving from Level Two to Level One
Preference is based on an awareness of the Authentic Self, the living being that is me, and the willingness to engage life. We have the awareness that in the present moment can take any direction, but there is a preference for a certain direction. Regardless of that preference, or the action we may take based on it, the awareness of the Authentic Self will endure. We can engage completely in the moment or concept.
Moving from Preference to the Authentic Self is simply the act of disengaging from our preferences as the moment passes. We can then reengage (attach) or disengage (detach) at will when we choose to live in the moment.
What Is the Authentic Self?
What’s in a name? That which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet.
—WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE
The level of the Authentic Self is a name or term that simply describes the living being that has the capacity to engage life. Our Authentic Self is present throughout each and every level; we simply have filters that block our awareness of it. We can choose to be our Authentic Self as a being who is completely free from attachment, if that is what we choose to be. This state can be temporarily reached through meditation and other similar practices. (I say temporarily because our awareness normally fluctuates throughout our lives as we engage the Dream of the Planet and are tempted by the mechanism of the judge and the victim.)
The Authentic Self is the living being that gives life to our bodies, enabling us to perceive and project life and interact with the Dream of the Planet; it is the energy that moves this pen across the paper until the being leaves this body. It is pure, unlimited potential.
“What is ‘me,’ if it’s not my identity or my Authentic Self?” is the question my knowledge asks of me. Even the label we are using—“the Authentic Self”—is a symbol to express something we want to understand. Who am I? This is one of the most important questions on the spiritual path. The answer cannot be put into words, yet I know that I exist. Just as I can say, “I am not this body,” I can also say, “I am not this mind.” I am just this living being giving both my body and my mind life—an empty definition whose meaning can only be determined by my yes or no.
The Five Levels of Attachment aren’t rules or guidelines for “achieving” Level One, the Authentic Self. The Five Levels are simply a framework to help us become aware of where we are at this moment in relation to the various things in our life. We can look at any situation and determine what is driving our thoughts and behavior as far as a particular attachment is concerned.
With awareness of how attached we are to a particular belief or idea, we regain something very important: our ability to make a choice, to say yes or no all over again. The true freedom we have as individuals is to be able to choose with full awareness of what we want and don’t want, instead of allowing our knowledge to dictate what we are supposed to be or choose. Our freedom to choose is true freedom; it is free will.
If we choose to remain attached to something that brings us pain, it is because that thing also comforts us in some way. Knowing this, we have the opportunity to further examine ourselves. If we are unaware, we go through life with blinders on, a slave to the distorted commentary of our narrators. But with awareness, we will be able to answer my grandmother’s question: “Is knowledge controlling you, or are you controlling knowledge?” The answer is the truth of where I am at this moment, and the truth will set me free.
When you are ready to let go of an attachment, all that is required to begin is a willingness to say, “Yes, I want to let go.” And that is the simple beauty of it. From a place of awareness, we no longer require the mechanism of the judge and victim to motivate ourselves. Our new motivator is passion, stoked only by unconditional love and recognition of our limitless potential to move forward in the trajectory of our choosing.
(don Miguel Ruiz Jr., The Five Levels of Attachment)