The Five Levels of Attachment: Chapter 3 – Knowledge and Attachments

If my attachment to what I know blinds me to all the available options, then my knowledge is controlling me; it is controlling my intention, and it is creating my Personal Dream for me. But with awareness of my attachments comes the opportunity to take back that control and to live as I choose.

Ever-Changing Meanings

I am only responsible for what I say; I am not responsible for what you hear. —DON MIGUEL RUIZ

Symbols are representations that allow us to understand one another’s experience of life. Words are symbols whose meanings and definitions give order to our experiences and allow us to communicate what we know. Words have an appealing but also very necessary and utilitarian function: they are the primary symbols allowing us to understand one another and create the agreements that build the Dream of Us, the Dream of the Planet. Take for example the word “sun.” In all of its translations, it is a symbol that represents the entity that illuminates our solar system. In the Toltec tradition, the sun represents the creation of life, where the Earth is the mother, the sun is the father, and the merging of the two creates life.

A symbol’s meaning is derived from agreement by a community, a culture, a nation, and so on. A definition is created by consensus—and when enough of us say yes to that representation, we call this knowledge.

For example, right now you are holding a book. “Book” is a symbol that represents the object in your hands. I could point to a book and you would know what it is because you can directly perceive it and you have past experience with it. You can still understand the concept of a book and visualize one even when neither one of us is holding one because of a previous tangible reference. There is very little at stake in agreeing that a bound collection of paper with words on it is a book.

However, there are symbols for ideas and concepts that we all manage differently based on our own perceptions and points of view. Love, spirit, morality—these symbols represent concepts that are defined by an agreement but can never be fully understood by someone else’s description or explanation. These symbols are virtual in the sense that they are intangible. When we use symbols to stand for concepts—whether we perceive them as good or bad or neutral—we are trying to give form to the formless. The more people who agree with us about a definition for an intangible concept, the more that idea seems to take form. This is why we refer to the Dream of the Planet as an illusion; the meaning of the symbols, the words, that construct our ideas and beliefs only feels solid through the agreement of the majority of individuals who are a part of that society or community. The building blocks of our society and our identity as a family or a nation are malleable and subject to change as individual dreams merge to create the Dream of the Planet through agreement and disagreement—yeses and nos.

For instance, when enough people come together and agree that a certain behavior is immoral—they have defined what it means to be immoral—that belief becomes more solid in appearance if a law is created reflecting that agreement. The people who engage in that behavior after the law is created are then labeled as “immoral” by the group that created the law. And if a law is broken, they will be punished accordingly.

But this consensus is an illusion because the idea of immorality never stops being virtual; it doesn’t exist “out there” somewhere, it only exists in the mental agreements we make. In order to maintain the illusion, the symbol and the attached belief require continuous support by the group of people. That continuous support is the very fuel that increases an individual’s attachment to a belief.

Because a virtual concept’s solidity is dependent on the agreement, the need for it to be real can be overpowering and all consuming. The attachment to the belief in the form of a symbol can become so great that those who ascribe to it cannot conceive of there being any other belief that can take its place. These symbols feel solid not only because we might agree with these virtual agreements but also because we can take action based on them. When we take action based on our ideas, it seems like we have manifested them as reality. But a symbol’s meaning is always still dependent on the agreement of an individual or society.

For example, there was a brief moment in time when a tulip was more valuable than gold. In the 1600s, during the Dutch Golden Age, the price of a tulip was ten times the annual income of a middle class merchant. The exotic flower, which was brought to Vienna from the Ottoman Empire in the 1500s, was in high demand for its beauty and soon became a symbol of status. When the mosaic virus decimated the population, making the wait for a single blooming tulip seven to twelve years (while also giving the infected tulips an even more exotic look), the price for the bulb skyrocketed. As a trader’s market for tulip bulbs developed, people began selling their personal property in order to buy bulbs and resell them later at a higher price. Unfortunately for these latecomers, the infatuation with tulips soon fizzled and the market collapsed. When the agreement about tulips changed many lost their financial worth, resulting in a massive economic downturn. But the tulip never stopped being a tulip. The financial worth was the illusion. The nature of these types of agreements is that their definitions are always subject to change.

When looked at this way, we can see how fragile and transient our definitions and meanings of ideas and concepts are. We can also see the great power they hold. This is precisely why we invest so much of our energy in trying to prove that our definitions and our interpretations of things are right. This is the fabric that constructs our reality.

However, when we become so attached to that reality, and to the meanings of the symbol that constructed that reality, we do not allow room for change and growth. We may find ourselves struggling, fighting, arguing with others (and with ourselves) to maintain our beliefs and definitions of the way things work, becoming prisoners of our own beliefs. It is through those beliefs that we have constructed the story of us. No wonder they elicit such an emotional reaction. But by becoming aware of the nature of our beliefs, we have the power to change our stories and our agreements. Since knowledge is the bridge that allows us to understand one another, it is an instrument by which we can create the dream or the reality in which we want to live. Our intention, or will, is the force that gives knowledge its meaning, expressed throughout our bodies onto the Dream of the Planet.

When each of us expresses something, we express it from the point of view of what we know. Listen closely, but receive all words and other symbols with skepticism. When you let go of your attachment to the meaning and the perceived truth that you apply to words and symbols—mine, yours, and others’—you have the freedom to step back and decide for yourself if those meanings reflect your experience in life. In addition, by openly listening to someone else’s expression of their knowledge without holding an attachment of what those symbols mean, you have the opportunity to better understand them.

Attachments and Our Sense of Self

When my family and I were moving from Arizona to Northern California, my little girl Audrey was three years old and had been in preschool for about a month. She loved our Arizona home and her school, so when we told her we were moving and she would be starting a new school, she became upset. “No, Dad! My school! My house! Mine!” she cried.

In the days that followed, she clung to everything in her life—us, her toys, her best friend at school, even her school principal. My wife and I kept telling her that she was going to be fine. She would be in a new school with new friends and it would all be great. When we picked her up from school that last day, Audrey flatly refused to leave, hiding behind the principal’s leg. In that moment, I paid very close attention to her. I imagined what the situation was like from her point of view: everything she knew would be going away. Her whole world was going to change, and she did not know who or what was going to remain. She grabbed hold of her friend Leo as he approached. “My Leo!” she cried. We eventually convinced her that it was time to go, and she reluctantly released her grasp on those things she had held so dear.

When we place ourselves in a safety zone where we feel comfortable and secure, and we are firmly entrenched in the this-is-who-I-am mindset, the worst thing imaginable is that it will all go away. And yet this happens again and again in varying degrees throughout our lives. When I believe something must stay in its rightful place, exactly as it is, for me to be OK, I have become attached to it, I have confused this external thing with who I am. If that external thing changes, and eventually everything does, how do I react? If I have placed my sense of self in it, then I have to defend it. I have to argue for it. I have to come up with definitions, and meaning. In short, I have created an attachment.

I know that I have put an attachment to a thing outside of myself when the fear of change takes hold of me. In change, the world I know can disappear, forcing me to go into the uncomfortable darkness of not knowing. But change is inevitable, and it arises time and time again throughout our lives: a relationship ends, we lose a job, leave a home, get a new wrinkle, a graying hair, or experience the death of a loved one, and so on.

If I look at all the things I have placed my sense of self in, I will find that my identity is placed in it. Fear comes when these things are threatened, because through my attachment I have interpreted these as being a part of myself; thus, an attachment is created to resist the possibility of that loss. When we look closely, we can notice how we’re always defending the object of our attachment in one way or another. In essence, we are defending our definition of self. This is what my little girl does when she goes around claiming “Mine!” It’s not just the object she is defending—it’s her sense of self. I’m happy to report that as soon as Audrey walked through the door of our new house, she became excited. She ran into her new room and exclaimed, “My room!”

The challenge I have for you is to change your agreement, to see yourself as a perfect human being, and to realize that there is no object, idea, or knowledge that you need to be complete. You are perfect because you are alive in this present moment, transforming continuously with life. If we can see ourselves as perfect just the way we are because we are alive at this moment, we are free. Our attachments no longer define us. Instead, the knowledge we gather becomes a tool that can help us decide how we want to engage in dreams—the personal and collective—and how we choose to act is the manifestation of our intention.

Looking at the story of your life, do you take action as dictated by your attachment to knowledge, or do you use knowledge to take an action based on the awareness of your present moment? My grandmother asked me many years ago: Is knowledge controlling you, or are you controlling knowledge? You can answer this for yourself when you come to know how attached you are to your knowledge, your beliefs, or something outside yourself. When I was first confronted with this question, I did not know that knowledge could lead us astray, causing us to suffer unless we take the helm. I did not know how to answer my grandmother’s question.

My grandmother believed that every attachment I form allows knowledge to control me. She spoke of heaven and hell, of demons and angels, of various levels of attachment and the consequences associated with them. This was her language, and it fit the experiences and context of her life. In the next chapter, I will explain the same teachings using an analogy reflecting our modern dream.

(don Miguel Ruiz Jr., The Five Levels of Attachment)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *